A laboratory tests three metal cylinders that are claimed to be made of the same material. For this problem, treat the listed measurements as exact and assume that cylinders made of the same material must have exactly the same mass-to-volume ratio.
- Cylinder A: volume \(20\,\text{cm}^3\), mass \(178\,\text{g}\)
- Cylinder B: volume \(50\,\text{cm}^3\), mass \(445\,\text{g}\)
- Cylinder C: volume \(12\,\text{cm}^3\), mass \(105\,\text{g}\)
a) Use calculations to determine whether the three measurements are consistent with that assumption.
b) What mass would Cylinder C need to have the same constant of proportionality as Cylinders A and B?
Hints
- Compare mass divided by volume for each cylinder.
- Under the stated assumption, what must be true about those ratios?
- For part b, use the common ratio from Cylinders A and B with Cylinder C's volume.
Solution
1. Cylinder A's density is \(178 \div 20=8.9\,\text{g/cm}^3\).
2. Cylinder B's density is \(445 \div 50=8.9\,\text{g/cm}^3\).
3. Cylinder C's density is \(105 \div 12=8.75\,\text{g/cm}^3\).
4. Since Cylinder C's ratio differs, the three measurements are not consistent with one exact mass-to-volume constant.
5. At \(8.9\,\text{g/cm}^3\), Cylinder C would need mass \(12\cdot8.9=106.8\,\text{g}\).
Answer
a) No. Cylinders A and B have density \(8.9\,\text{g/cm}^3\), while Cylinder C has density \(8.75\,\text{g/cm}^3\), so the three exact measurements do not share one constant ratio.
b) \(106.8\,\text{g}\).