The seven ordered pairs are
\((1,5)\), \((2,6)\), \((2,8)\), \((3,7)\), \((4,10)\), \((5,9)\), and \((6,12)\).
Noah's candidate scatter plot also contains seven points. Exactly one required ordered pair is missing, and exactly one plotted point does not belong to the data. Identify the missing pair and the extra point. Is it an error that two correct points have \(x=2\)? Explain.

Hints
- Check the candidate plot against the complete list of ordered pairs one pair at a time.
- Having the same \(x\)-coordinate does not force two observations to have the same \(y\)-coordinate.
- The missing and extra points must account for why both the list and the graph still contain seven observations.
Solution
1. Compare the seven listed ordered pairs with the seven displayed markers.
2. The listed pair \((5,9)\) does not appear on the candidate plot, so it is the missing pair.
3. The candidate plot contains \((5,11)\), which is not in the data, so it is the extra point.
4. The two points \((2,6)\) and \((2,8)\) are both correct. A scatter plot may have repeated \(x\)-values because different observations can share the same value of one variable.
Answer
The missing pair is \((5,9)\), and the extra plotted point is \((5,11)\). No, the repeated value \(x=2\) is not an error; both \((2,6)\) and \((2,8)\) are valid observations.