Consider \(e^{-x}=\sin(x)\) for \(x\geq0\).
a) Show that the equation has exactly two solutions in \([0, \pi]\).
b) Explain why it has no solutions in \([\pi, 2\pi]\).
c) Determine whether it has finitely or infinitely many solutions for \(x\geq0\). Justify your answer.
Hints
- Study the sign of \(\sin(x)-e^{-x}\) at key points.
- Use concavity to limit the number of zeros in \([0, \pi]\).
- Identify intervals where \(\sin(x)\leq0\).
- Repeat the argument on each positive half-wave of sine.
Solution
1. Let \(h(x)=\sin(x)-e^{-x}\). Then \(h(0)=-1<0\), \(h\!\left(\frac{\pi}{2}\right)=1-e^{-\pi/2}>0\), and \(h(\pi)=-e^{-\pi}<0\). The Intermediate Value Theorem gives at least two zeros in \([0, \pi]\).
2. On \((0, \pi)\), \(h''(x)=-\sin(x)-e^{-x}<0\), so \(h\) is strictly concave. A strictly concave function cannot cross the \(x\)-axis more than twice when it is negative at both endpoints and positive at an interior point. Thus, there are exactly two solutions.
3. On \([\pi, 2\pi]\), \(\sin(x)\leq0\) while \(e^{-x}>0\), so there is no solution.
4. For every nonnegative integer \(k\), on \([2k\pi, (2k+1)\pi]\), the sine function is \(0\) at both endpoints and \(1\) at the midpoint, while \(e^{-x}\) is positive and less than \(1\) at the midpoint. Therefore, there are at least two solutions in each such interval. The equation has infinitely many solutions.
Answer
a) Let \(h(x)=\sin x-e^{-x}\). Its values at \(0\), \(\frac\pi2\), and \(\pi\) have signs \(-,+,-\), respectively, so continuity gives at least two zeros. Since \(h''(x)=-\sin x-e^{-x}<0\) for \(0<x<\pi\), \(h\) is strictly concave; three distinct zeros would force the middle zero to lie strictly above the chord joining the outer two zeros, a contradiction. Thus there are exactly two solutions in \([0,\pi]\).
b) On \([\pi,2\pi]\), \(\sin x\le0\), while \(e^{-x}>0\), so equality is impossible.
c) On every interval \([2k\pi,(2k+1)\pi]\) with integer \(k\ge0\), the difference \(h\) is negative at the endpoints and positive at the midpoint \(\frac\pi2+2k\pi\). Continuity gives at least two roots in each of these infinitely many disjoint intervals. Therefore, there are infinitely many solutions for \(x\ge0\).